Critics Slam Call-Ahead Charges: "Advance Notifications Saves a Fortune"
In an effort to address the growing demand for electric vehicles (EVs) in Germany, Jutta Geldermann, a researcher at the University of Duisburg-Essen, has developed a methodology for strategically planning EV charging infrastructure in densely populated areas. This approach, which integrates multiple critical factors, aims to optimize the placement and operation of charging stations, potentially reducing costs by up to 50 percent.
Key Aspects of the Methodology:
1. **Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis (MCDA):** By evaluating and prioritizing locations and infrastructure options based on various criteria, such as technical feasibilities, economic factors, and social aspects, the approach ensures a strategic and data-driven approach to planning.
2. **Modeling Traffic Flows:** Analyzing detailed traffic data helps identify hotspots where EV users are likely to need charging, taking into account peak traffic hours, common routes, and parking availability.
3. **Incorporation of Electricity Price Variability:** The methodology considers dynamic electricity pricing to optimize charging times and station operation, potentially recommending smart charging solutions that align with cheaper electricity periods or grid load management needs.
4. **User Behavior Analysis:** Behavioral data, such as typical charging durations, preferences for charging locations, and willingness to pay, are integrated to tailor infrastructure planning to real-world usage patterns.
5. **Spatial Optimization Models:** Advanced spatial optimization techniques are employed to determine the optimal number, type, and placement of charging stations to maximize accessibility and minimize costs.
6. **Scenario and Sensitivity Analysis:** The methodology allows planners to simulate different future scenarios, testing the robustness and flexibility of the proposed infrastructure in the face of rising EV adoption rates, changes in electricity tariffs, and other factors.
Geldermann's approach is a response to concerns about the automotive industry's demand for one million public charging points by 2030, as she argues that such numbers are not meaningful without clear planning for placement and utilization. She also emphasizes the need for more coordination among municipalities, utilities, gas station operators, and service providers like EnBW or E.ON.
A study by the University of Duisburg-Essen calculated that 118 strategically placed charging points are sufficient to cover 800 locations for 500 electric vehicles in the city of Essen. However, the model used in the study takes into account traffic flows, electricity prices, and the expected energy mix in 2030.
Despite the potential benefits of Geldermann's methodology, it has received little attention, which she attributes to external factors like the COVID-19 pandemic and a hacker attack on the university. Providers like EnBW are slowing down the expansion of charging infrastructure, citing low utilization and economic risks.
Geldermann hopes that in the future, utilities, car manufacturers, and charging service providers will work more closely with science to create a more effective and sustainable charging infrastructure network in Germany.
- Jutta Geldermann's methodology, developed for strategically planning electric vehicle (EV) charging infrastructure, incorporates Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis (MCDA) to guarantee a strategic, data-driven approach.
- The approach also involves modeling traffic flows, which allows for the identification of areas with high EV user demand, taking into account factors like common routes, peak traffic hours, and parking availability.
- In addition, the methodology considers the incorporation of electricity price variability to optimize charging times and station operation, potentially recommending smart charging solutions aligned with cheaper electricity periods or grid load management needs.
