Skimming the Scam: The Nate App's AI Deception
Ex-Nate CEO Accused of Fraud Over $40M Investment Based on Bogus AI Declarations
Table of Contents
Toggle*
- Albert Saniger Tangled in Securities and Wire Fraud Scandal
- Nate App Marketed on Empty Promises
- Manual Labor Masked as AI Magic
- Millions Down the Rabbit Hole
- Nate's Shady Operations Exposed
- Calling the Bluff on AI Hype
Albert Saniger, the founder and ex-CEO of the shopping app Nate, has been hit with charges of securities and wire fraud by US authorities. According to these charges, Saniger deceptively marketed his shopping app as an AI-powered innovation, using it to dupe investors.
The app, launched in 2020, promised to simplify online shopping with a single-tap checkout. Advertisements showcased a seamless experience and claimed that Nate's "AI" could process over 10,000 transactions daily. However, the alleged reality was far from these impressive figures.
Behind the Curtain
Saniger claimed that Nate relied on cutting-edge AI, leveraging custom-built "deep learning models." Yet, beneath the surface, the app operated with a cast of hundreds of human workers tucked away in a call center in the Philippines, manually managing transactions to create the illusion of AI magic.
Acting US Attorney for New York, Matthew Podolsky, stated that Saniger exploited the allure of AI technology to dupe investors. Saniger allegedly succeeded in raising over $40 million using this false narrative of innovation, which never materialized.
Complicating matters further, Saniger is accused of instructing employees to keep the human involvement in the transactions a secret while misleading investors by presenting the app's operations as entirely automated by AI technology.
Unraveling the Deception
Matters came to a head when The Information published an investigation in 2022 questioning Nate's AI claims. As a result, the company reportedly ran out of money and sold off its assets in January 2023, leaving investors with heavy losses.
Hollow Hype: AI in Question
The Nate app case is not an isolated incident. In 2023, it was reported that another tech startup relied heavily on humans—this time a drive-through software company—to pass off their work as AI-driven. More recently, Business Insider revealed that EvenUp, an AI legal tech company, used significant human intervention instead of relying on advanced automation as claimed.
Consequences of Deception
Saniger faces penalties of up to 20 years in prison for engaging in schemes to defraud investors by making false statements about Nate's AI capabilities. The Securities and Exchange Commission also aims to bar him from holding any position in similar companies and recover investor funds.
With Nate ceasing operations in January 2023, Saniger left all employees behind and moved on. His current position is listed as a managing partner at Buttercore Partners in New York. Neither Saniger nor Buttercore Partners have responded to requests for comment regarding the charges.
As awareness grows around AI claims in startups, the Nate app case serves as a stark reminder of the risks of baseless technology claims and their potential to mislead investors. In this era of rapid innovation, it's crucial to maintain transparency and integrity to preserve trust and progress.
- The deceptive practices of Nate's founder, Albert Saniger, have raised concerns about the use of AI in general-news, particularly in the tech industry.
- Despite the Nate app being marketed as an AI-powered innovation, the reality was far from it, as it relied on human workers instead, a case that highlights the need for transparency and integrity in crime-and-justice cases involving technology.
