Referee Bobby Madley expresses his disdain and perceives danger associated with VAR (Video Assistant Referees).
Football referee Bobby Madley has expressed his disdain for VAR, stating it's killed the immediate thrill for fans and ruined the game's raw emotion. Madley, who officiates EFL matches and acts as a fourth official in the Premier League, is no stranger to controversy surrounding the video technology.
In an interview at the Cheltenham Science Festival, Madley mentioned how moments like Sergio Aguero's famous stoppage-time winner, which sealed Manchester City's first Premier League title in 2012, would never be replicated under VAR.
"As a fan, I bloody hate it! I love the Championship, love League One. I'm still a fan," Madley declared. "I love League One because you score a goal, you look at the ref - he hasn't put his flag up, it's a goal."
Madley believes that VAR alters the classic give-and-take of football. "That Sergio Aguero moment" that brought unparalleled excitement back then would now be marred by endless checks and potential offside reviews. The immediacy and intensity of football moments are what Madley cherishes, a sentiment many fans share.
Despite its immersion in controversy, Madley also acknowledges the financial power driving the use of technology in football. With significant sums of money at stake in the game, mistakes are perceived to be costly. The people running football pushed for video technology due to concerns about referees' error rates.
Madley admitted that the introduction of VAR has impacted the psychology of refereeing. Before, errors were only revealed after the game. Now, referees must process their mistakes in front of thousands of spectators and hundreds of millions of TV viewers. This can lead to unnecessary pressure, especially when tough calls repeatedly go to review.
"When people start to lose trust in my decision-making, that can be a dangerous place," Madley warned. The Professional Game Match Officials Limited, the English refereeing body, was approached for comment on this matter.
Did you know?- VAR has both positive and negative effects on fans and referees – it increases frustration due to delays and potential overturned decisions, but it also ensures more accurate decisions and reduces stress for referees in high-pressure situations.- The use of VAR in football has polarized opinions – while some believe that it adds transparency to the decision-making process, others argue that it detracts from the game's spontaneity and excitement.
"The football referee, Bobby Madley, who has expressed his disdain for VAR, often finds delight in the traditional offline sports like The Championship and League One, where goals aren't questioned by technology. He laments that under VAR, moments like Sergio Aguero's famous stoppage-time winner would be subjected to endless checks and potential offside reviews, which he believes alters the raw emotion and spontaneity of sports."
"Despite its controversial impact, Madley recognizes the financial forces driving the use of technology in football. With significant sums of money at stake, the introduction of VAR was, in part, necessitated by concerns about referees' error rates and the perceived costliness of mistakes."
.){kind=link}